We currently own a used 2013 Toyota Innova along with a 2013 Swift, and use the Innova for both long journeys and daily driving. We bought it for Rs 8 lakh. Now, we are considering either a used 2016 Innova or an Innova Crysta. We need good mileage, diesel, comfort and good looks. What should we buy, and what should we check before purchasing?

autocar.india

•2d

Go for the Toyota Innova Crysta as it is the better family car here. It is more comfortable, more spacious and more stable on the highway, which is exactly what you want in a big diesel family car. The Scorpio N is the more exciting car to drive, but the Crysta is the car you will appreciate more over years of ownership.On the 3-airbag question: it's only on the lower variants while the higher variant come with 7 airbags . The Crysta is a fundamentally strong and well-engineered car with a proven safety record so it shouldn't be a cause for concern. The Scorpio N does get more safety features, but the Crysta's overall package of comfort, reliability and long-term ownership experience outweighs that.You are coming from an Eon, so this is a big upgrade. The Crysta will feel like a huge step up in comfort, space and refinement.

Toyota Innova Crysta

Mahindra Scorpio N

autocar.india

•4d

Go for the Skoda Kylaq Classic Plus AT. Since she prefers an upright seating position and an SUV stance, the Kylaq is the better fit. The higher seating position gives a better view of the road, which is reassuring for a first-time driver, and the SUV-like stance makes it easier to judge the car’s corners in traffic. The 6-speed torque converter automatic is smooth and predictable, making city driving stress-free, but there is turbo lag which needs getting used to. Aside from that, the Kyalq is a good choice, compact enough to be easy to park and manoeuvre, while still feeling more substantial and confidence-inspiring than a hatchback.The Maruti Suzuki Swift ZXI+ AMT is a great city car and very easy to drive, but the AGS (AMT) gearbox is not as smooth as the Kylaq’s torque converter automatic, especially in stop-start traffic. Since you already own an Hyundai i20, the Swift would feel like a similar experience, whereas the Kylaq offers a genuinely different and more confidence-inspiring driving position. The Kylaq is the better long-term choice for her needs.

Skoda Kylaq

Maruti Suzuki Swift

Hyundai i20

autocar.india

•17h

For your usage, the Punch petrol manual would be a better fit than the Altroz petrol. Its 193mm ground clearance and good ride quality make it better suited to Himachal and Jammu & Kashmir roads, while the 88hp 1.2-litre petrol has enough pulling power for three to four adults as long as expectations are realistic.The Punch AMT would not be our pick for this usage. The 1.2 petrol is already not particularly strong when fully loaded and climbing, and the AMT can feel slow when you need a quick response. The turbo petrol is considerably stronger at 120hp and 170Nm, but it is manual only, so the 1.2 manual is the sensible choice if you want to stay close to Rs 10-11 lakh.If you are willing to stretch towards Rs 12 lakh, the Skoda Kylaq 1.0 TSI AT would also be worth considering, particularly if you want stronger highway performance and an automatic.

Tata Punch

Tata Altroz

Skoda Kylaq