Latest questions answered by experts

Hi team, I have a Hyundai EON (Era Plus) model which I bought in March 2012. As I am nearing the 15-year mark, I wanted to know whether I should continue with it for another 5 years by paying the environmental tax or should I consider upgrading to a new car. My total running is not very high, around 25k kms and it generally gets driven only during the weekends, as my office commute is through an office cab. In the last 2-3 years, I have developed a habit of occasional long drives else its mostly city driving. The vehicle has a BS III engine and 819 cc. I changed all four wheels of my car in 2024. Overall, the condition of the car is good, and I haven't faced any major issues so far; more importantly, I am happy with the car. But I need an opinion on: 1) Whether I can continue using it for another 5 years by paying environment tax? 2) Given the scenario of making E20 mandatory, my car won't support E20 fuel as of now; are there any chances/ scope there will be normal petrol will still be available to support older model cars? 3) Any other factors that I need to consider/ think of before making a decision? Thanks for the help in advance

•26m

You are happy with the car; it is mechanically sound, and your running is low. In this scenario, the most sensible decision is to keep the Eon for another five years. Paying the environment tax is a one-time cost, and as long as the car is well maintained, there is no reason to replace it purely because of age. The Eon is a simple, reliable car and for weekend city use with occasional long drives, it is likely to continue to do the job well.The only factors to consider are the car's condition and your own needs. If the car is rust-free, mechanically healthy, and you are happy with it, there is no financial logic in replacing it. If you start doing more long-distance driving and want better comfort, safety and performance, then an upgrade makes sense. Otherwise, keep the Eon and enjoy the low running costs.

•29m

Rear legroom on the Virtus is genuinely better than the brochure numbers suggested once you actually sit behind someone my height.

•53m

Infotainment on my Compass freezes for a few seconds almost every time I switch from Android Auto back to the native interface.

•6h

I’m currently driving a Honda City MT i-VTEC as my daily driver in the city, but I’m not happy with its mileage. My daily usage in the city is around 20-30 km. I’ve shortlisted the Kia Seltos MT Diesel and MG Windsor. Please suggest which of these would be the better choice. Thanks.

•1h

With a daily city usage of 20-30 km, a diesel Seltos is not the right choice. Modern diesels need regular highway runs to keep the DPF healthy, and your usage pattern is predominantly short city trips. The fuel savings from diesel will also take a very long time to justify the higher purchase cost at your running.If you can arrange for home charging, the MG Windsor EV seems to be a better fit for your usage. This MG car is a very spacious, comfortable family car with a premium feel. Since your usage isn't much, you could consider the small battery version instead of the Pro - it'll be more affordable.

Kia Seltos

MG Windsor

•8h

Hello, I have been using a Creta manual for the past 11 years. I have now sold my Creta and am planning to buy a Seltos automatic. Please suggest which automatic variant would be better for me - petrol or diesel. My annual running is around 10,000- 12,000 km. Should I go for the diesel or petrol automatic?

•2h

With 10,000-12,000 km a year, the decision between petrol and diesel comes down to your usage pattern. Sure, a diesel automatic will be a bit more economical to run; however, you are paying a higher premium upfront. Hence, we'd suggest you pick the Kia Seltos 1.5 Petrol IVT version, which is smoother, quieter and easier to live with in stop-start traffic, and you will not have to worry about DPF-related issues that can arise with modern diesels if the car is not regularly driven on periodic highway runs.Pick the diesel automatic only if you do regular highway runs for its stronger performance and more effortless cruising ability. The diesel's fuel efficiency will be better too.

Kia Seltos

•2h

Paddle shifters on the Thar Roxx sound exciting on paper, but in actual city traffic I've used them maybe twice since delivery.

•8h

Hi, I am from Mumbai and have a family of 5. I am looking for a car with a budget of around Rs. 20 lakh. I will mostly be driving in Mumbai, with occasional trips to Valsad. I am looking for a car with an automatic transmission and good long-term reliability.

•3h

The Kia Carens Clavis Turbo DCT is an excellent family car that should fall within your Rs 20 lakh (on-road) budget. It is a spacious, comfortable and feature-loaded car, and its turbo-petrol engine is smooth with good performance and respectable range when driven in Eco mode. For your occasional long-distance drives, this car will easily accommodate all the passengers and their luggage (with one-half of or the entire last row folded down). Alternatively, you could consider the Maruti XL6 too, which is a 6-seater version of the Ertiga. It is a reliable, dependable option, backed by Maruti's widespread service network.

360 camera on the Kylaq gets noticeably grainy at night, makes tight parking spots a bit of a guessing game after dark.

•1d

I currently own a Hyundai Venue 1.2 petrol. I am considering for an upgrade and my requirements include a 7-seater petrol or diesel automatic SUV under 25 lakh (on-road) with 80:20 city to highway ratio with maximum 15,000 km annually. Can I consider electric as well. What would be your recommendation? I am considering XUV 7X0, Safari or the Alcazar but I'm open to other options as well. Thanks in advance.

•3h

Given your requirements, the Mahindra XUV 7XO diesel automatic would be our recommendation. With an 80:20 city-to-highway ratio and 15,000 km a year, diesel still makes sense because the XUV 7XO's diesel engine is refined, efficient and well suited to both city driving and long highway runs. The 7XO also offers a usable third row, strong performance and a well-equipped cabin, making it a proper upgrade from your Venue.The Tata Safari is a strong alternative if you prioritise ride comfort and a more spacious third row, but the XUV 7XO offers a better overall ownership experience and a more modern feature set. The Hyundai Alcazar petrol automatic is the more refined and easier-to-drive option in the city, but its third row is tighter and it does not feel like as big a step up from the Venue.On the electric front, the Mahindra XEV 9S is worth considering if you have home charging and predictable daily usage, but at Rs. 25 lakh on-road you are likely to be looking at the lower variants, and the XUV 7XO diesel still makes more sense given your usage pattern.Overall, the XUV 7XO diesel automatic strikes the best balance between space, performance, efficiency and long-term ownership.

•4h

Some dealers are quietly adding a handling charge on top of the ex-showroom price for the Creta Electric because demand is outpacing supply right now.

•1d

I am planning to buy a 7-seater SUV and am considering the Mahindra Scorpio-N Z8L. However, I’m confused about which variant and powertrain would be best for me among petrol or diesel, and manual or automatic. My monthly running is around 400-500 km. I’m concerned that if I choose the petrol version, I might face a mileage issue. On the other hand, if I choose the diesel version, I’m worried that the low running could lead to DPF-related issues. Most of my driving is on highways, with around 300 km per month on highways and the remaining 100-200 km in the city. Could you please suggest which option would be more suitable for my usage? I would also appreciate if you could provide a comparison of the maintenance costs, fuel efficiency, and long-term ownership costs of the petrol and diesel versions, as well as manual vs. automatic.

•4h

Go for the Mahindra Scorpio N Z8L diesel automatic. Your usage is predominantly on the highway, and the diesel engine is the better fit for this. The Scorpio N diesel is a strong performer on the highway, with good torque and effortless cruising ability, and the automatic gearbox makes long drives far more comfortable and stress-free. Your monthly running is low, but because most of it is highway driving, the diesel engine will regularly meet the conditions needed to keep the DPF system healthy, so DPF-related issues are unlikely to be a concern.The petrol engine is smooth and refined, but it is a large, heavy SUV and fuel efficiency will be noticeably lower than the diesel. In terms of maintenance costs, the diesel will be slightly higher over the long term, but the difference is not significant enough to outweigh the benefits of better fuel efficiency and stronger highway performance. Between manual and automatic, the automatic is the clear choice for a car like the Scorpio N. It is a big, heavy SUV and the automatic gearbox makes it much easier to drive both in the city and on the highway.Overall, the diesel automatic is the best fit for your usage and will give you the most satisfying ownership experience.

Mahindra Scorpio N

•4h

First heavy rain of the season and the panoramic sunroof on my Victoris let in a small amount of water near the seal. Booking a service appointment before it becomes a bigger issue.

•22h

I stay in Hyderabad and travel 25-30 km daily. I go out once in a month covering approximately 600km. I have recently sold my XUV 700 diesel and am confused whether I should go for an electric car or hybrid petrol. My budget is approximately 20 lakh (can extend it by 2 lakh). Please guide.

•4h

With a 25-30 km daily commute and a monthly 600 km highway trip, the decision comes down to charging convenience and long-term ownership. If you have reliable home charging, an EV like the Tata Nexon EV or Hyundai Creta Electric makes strong financial sense. Your daily running is well within their range, and the low running costs will add up over time. The Creta Electric is a proven product and offers a more modern cabin and a more premium feel than the Nexon EV.If you do not have home charging or are not comfortable planning charging stops on your monthly highway trips, a hybrid is the safer choice. The Maruti Suzuki Victoris Hybrid is the best fit in your budget. It delivers excellent fuel efficiency in the city and on the highway, and you never have to worry about charging.Given your usage, the EV is the better financial decision if home charging is available. If not, the Victoris Hybrid is the more practical long-term ownership proposition.

Maruti Suzuki Victoris

Hyundai Creta Electric

Tata Nexon EV

•5h

Every dealership near me has exactly one Windsor EV test drive unit, and it's booked out almost two weeks in advance.

•20h

I own a Skoda Slavia Sportline that I had purchased in December 2025. After reading about so many BaaS offers on electric vehicles viz XEV 9S, where the registration charges are zero in Maharashtra, it is tempting to exchange my current car for an electric car. Should I do that? My monthly running is around 1000 km. Also, is BaaS available for the Sierra EV?

•5h

With a monthly running of around 1,000 km, an EV can make sense, but only if you have a predictable usage pattern and access to home charging. The bigger question is whether it makes sense to exchange your Slavia, which is a relatively new and well-rounded car. The Slavia offers a great driving experience, good comfort and is a proven product. The XEV 9S is a very different proposition – it is a large, premium electric SUV with a very different ownership and usage profile.The BaaS (Battery as a Service) scheme on the XEV 9S is attractive because it reduces the upfront cost, but it also means you are paying a monthly subscription for the battery, which only makes sense if you are committed to long-term EV ownership and your usage pattern justifies it. The Sierra EV does not currently offer a BaaS scheme.Our advice would be to hold on to the Slavia for now. It is still a very capable car and you are unlikely to recover its value in a trade-in so soon after purchase. If you are keen on an EV, wait for a few more years until your Slavia has served its purpose and the EV market has matured further. If you are set on an EV today, the XEV 9S with BaaS is a good option.

Sierra deliveries are apparently still getting delayed occasionally because of a specific chip shortage, didn't expect that to still be a thing in 2026.

•10h

I went to book a Hyundai Creta but seeing the stylish Verna next to Creta, took its test drive. The seat and ambience seem way better than any car and have almost decided to go with Verna but I have one doubt about its ground clearance. Since I will be driving the car in Chennai city and on highways with occasional patchy roads, even if scrapping occurs rarely, will it be a costly affair to repair?

•7h

Go for the Hyundai Verna. Your usage in the city and highways with only occasional patchy roads is exactly the kind of scenario where the Verna works well. It offers a more premium cabin, a lower seating position and a more engaging driving experience than the Creta, which is why it felt so good on the test drive. The ground clearance is lower than the Creta, but it is not a deal-breaker. On rare occasions, you may scrape the underbody on a badly designed speed breaker or a deep pothole, but this is usually limited to minor scrapes on the underbody cladding or the exhaust heat shield. These are not expensive to repair and do not affect the car's reliability or safety. The Verna is a well-engineered sedan and can handle occasional rough patches without issue. If you are still concerned, you can take speed breakers at an angle and slow down on bad patches, which will minimise the chances of scraping. Overall, the Verna will give you a enjoyable ownership experience, and the ground clearance is not a reason to avoid it.

Hyundai Verna

Hyundai Creta

•9h

I currently own a petrol Maruti Suzuki Ertiga purchased in 2021, that has covered around 85,000 km. It currently gives me around 7-8 kpl in city driving, so increasing fuel costs have made me consider switching to a CNG car. I also no longer require the Ertiga's third-row seats, as my son and daughter are now in college, so a five-seater would be sufficient for my needs. I am interested in the CNG and AMT combination, as I am 48 years old and believe an automatic transmission would make frequent city driving and traffic much less tiring. Currently, I am considering Tata Punch Adventure S CNG AMT, Tata Altroz Creative S CNG AMT, Maruti Suzuki Brezza ZXi CNG, Maruti Suzuki Brezza VXi CNG and Maruti Suzuki Baleno Zeta CNG. The Punch Adventure S CNG AMT is currently my preferred choice because it seems to offer a good balance of features, practicality and running costs. At its price, I also get more features, a CNG + AMT combination and what appears to be a very strong safety package. I was also considering the Brezza ZXi and VXi CNG, particularly for their larger size and Maruti's reputation for reliability. However, the lack of a proper spare wheel concerns me, as I have experienced tyre punctures several times. My budget is a maximum of Rs. 14 lakh. I am also unsure whether an electric car under Rs. 14 lakh would be suitable for me, as I would prefer to avoid range anxiety at this point. Based on your road tests and experience, which of these cars would you recommend? Is the Punch Adventure S CNG AMT the best choice for my requirements, or should I seriously consider one of the other options? Also, is there another car I may have overlooked?

•7h

Based on your requirements, the Tata Punch Adventure S CNG AMT is a very sensible choice. It offers the CNG + AMT combination you are looking for, a strong safety package and a higher seating position that makes city driving less tiring. The Punch is also well priced for what it offers and is a genuinely practical five-seater.That said, the Maruti Suzuki Brezza ZXi CNG is still worth serious consideration. It is a larger car with a more powerful engine, better rear seat space and a more comfortable ride over broken roads. Maruti's service network and long-term reliability track record are also strong advantages. The lack of a proper spare wheel is a drawback, but it is not a deal-breaker if you are comfortable carrying a puncture repair kit and using roadside assistance.The Tata Altroz Creative S CNG AMT is also a good option if you prefer a more premium hatchback experience, but it does not offer the same ground clearance or seating position as the Punch.On the electric car question, you are right to be cautious. Most EVs under Rs. 14 lakh have relatively modest real-world range, and unless you have a predictable daily commute and home charging, range anxiety can be a genuine concern.Overall, the Punch Adventure S CNG AMT is the best fit for your requirements. It offers the right balance of fuel efficiency, ease of driving, safety and practicality for your current needs. The Brezza ZXi CNG is the better choice if you prioritise space, power and long-term ownership confidence. Both are strong options, so the final decision comes down to whether you value the Punch's CNG + AMT combination and higher seating position more than the Brezza's size and Maruti ownership experience.

•20h

Hi everyone, I have a budget around 13 lakh and my annual running is around 8,000 km. I'm confused between buying a sedan or compact SUV like Kia Seltos etc. as I have sold my Tata Punch last month that I owned almost for 4.5 years but now I want to purchase good and elegant looking car that can last for 7 to 9 year without any hassle. Me and my wife have shortlisted cars like New Honda City SV variant, New Skoda Slavia Base one, or Upcoming Virtus in sedan segment. In suv segment, I have shortlisted cars like Seltos, Grand Vitara, etc. My wife wants to shortlist sedan. Please suggest me which one should I go for as it's the matter of investing my hard earned money. Also, which car will have good resale value in future.

•8h

Go for the Honda City SV petrol manual. With your annual running of 8,000km, petrol is the right choice, and the City is one of the most reliable and hassle-free cars you can buy. It is also a car that is known to last well beyond 7-9 years with proper maintenance, which fits your ownership plan. The SV variant gives you the essentials within your budget, and the City’s strong resale value and Honda's wide service network make it a sensible long-term investment.The Skoda Slavia and Volkswagen Virtus are both excellent to drive, but the City is the safer long-term bet. Skoda and Volkswagen have improved their ownership experience, but Honda still has the edge when it comes to reliability and peace of mind over a long ownership period. On the SUV side, the Seltos and Grand Vitara are both good cars, but at your budget you will be looking at base variants, and neither will have as much resale as the City.Since your wife prefers a sedan and you are looking for a car that will last without hassle, the Honda City SV is the best option.

Maruti Suzuki Grand Vitara

•1d

I am new to driving and am looking for a sub-4-metre petrol SUV with a torque converter automatic gearbox. My budget is under Rs 10 lakh ex-showroom. I have shortlisted two options: Skoda Kylaq Classic+ automatic at Rs 9.25 lakh and Mahindra XUV 3XO MX2 Pro automatic at Rs 9.99 lakh. We are a family of five. My current usage is mostly in the city, but in the future it could become a 50:50 mix of city and highway driving. The Kylaq does not get an infotainment system, although the dealer is offering one for around Rs 30,000. Its rear seat is also narrower than the XUV 3XO's. The XUV 3XO does not get cruise control, LED lights or driver-seat adjustment. Both cars offer similar fuel efficiency. Which one would be the better choice for me?

•9h

Go for the XUV 3XO MX2 Pro automatic. As a new driver with a family of five, the Mahindra XUV 3XO is the more practical and comfortable choice. It has a wider rear seat, which makes a big difference for three passengers, and the cabin feels more spacious overall. The 1.2 turbo petrol engine paired with the 6-speed torque converter automatic is smooth and easy to drive, and the car feels stable and confident on the highway.The Skoda Kylaq is a good driver's car, but the narrower rear seat and the need to add an aftermarket infotainment system make it less appealing for family use. The missing features on the 3XO, like cruise control and LED lights, are not deal-breakers at this price point. Overall, the Mahindra car offers a better balance of space, comfort and value for a family of five.

Mahindra XUV 3XO

Skoda Kylaq

Need expert advice?

Ask the Autocar community and experts.

Latest questions answered by experts

Need expert advice for your car?

Can't decide between two cars?

Worried about service and upkeep?