Toyota Rumion

autocar.india

•22w

You haven't mentioned your budget, but since you're considering a brand new Toyota Innova Crysta GX Plus variant, it is safe to assume that you're comfortable spending close to Rs 25 lakhs (on-road). Since this vehicle will be used for commercial purposes, it would be better to buy a new car to start with. You will be able to claim tax refunds as well as benefit from asset depreciation in your company's books. Additionally, you get the peace of mind of a new vehicle, and the backing of a company warranty.To address the second part of your question, the Maruti Ertiga VXI MT or Toyota Rumion S MT costs half as much as an Innova Crysta GX Plus, resulting in a tremendous saving. In fact, you can even buy two cars for the price of one Innova. Both, Ertiga and Rumion are equally reliable. And even though these are petrol-powered, they're quite fuel efficient, and their maintenance costs will be lower than that of the diesel Crysta. Between the Ertiga and Rumion, even though they're the same, the Toyota is a bit more expensive, hence purely from a savings perspective, the Ertiga makes more sense.Overall, all three cars you've listed are reliable, dependable, and are backed by the widespread, strong network of Toyota and Maruti. It is up to you to decide whether you want to buy a new Crysta GX or if you're happy to buy one, or even examples of the Maruti Ertiga and Toyota Rumion.Whichever you pick, these are cars you can't go wrong with.

Toyota Innova Crysta

Maruti Suzuki Ertiga

Toyota Rumion

autocar.india

•1w

Given your requirements, the Maruti Suzuki Ertiga CNG is the most sensible recommendation. Your monthly running of around 1,000 km, with occasional spikes, does not justify a diesel, especially with the higher purchase cost and maintenance associated with modern diesel engines. The Ertiga CNG strikes the right balance between low running costs, reliability and practicality. It is a proven 7-seater with a comfortable ride, good service network and low maintenance costs, which is important given your plan to keep the car for 7-10 years. The CNG system is factory-fitted and well-integrated, making it a far better option than any aftermarket CNG installation. The only drawback is the reduced boot space with the CNG tank, but for your usage pattern and occasional rental plans, the overall cost savings outweigh this limitation. If you need more space and comfort, the Maruti Suzuki XL6 CNG is a good alternative, offering a more premium cabin and captain seats in the middle row making it a strict 6-seater, but the Ertiga remains the more value-driven choice. Alternatively, there is also the Toyota Rumion, which is Toyota's version of the Ertiga so if there is a lower waiting time, you can check out the Rumion too.

Maruti Suzuki XL6

Toyota Rumion

Maruti Suzuki Ertiga

autocar.india

•5w

Go with the Maruti Suzuki Ertiga for your 80% city use. You get petrol or CNG, so no DPF drama in short, stop-go runs, and there’s an easy automatic for traffic. It’s lighter to steer, rides more comfortably over broken roads, and its third row is actually usable for adults on short trips.The Bolero Neo certainly has its appeal with its commanding seating position and rugged character, but its diesel and ladder-frame make it a harder life in the city. Lots of short trips can trigger frequent DPF regens, and the last row is side-facing, cramped, and doesn't have seatbelts, so it's not great for family safety or comfort. It’s manual-only and heavier to drive, too.If you still want more style and space without diesel worries, the Kia Carens petrol is a nice middle path. Very easy in town, flexible 7-seat cabin, with an even roomier third row. The Toyota Rumion is basically an Ertiga with the Toyota badge and similar strengths, so buy whichever gives you the better deal or service comfort.

Maruti Suzuki Ertiga

Kia Carens

Toyota Rumion