Opinion: Are badge swaps really that bad?

    The Rumion is the fourth badge-engineered model between Maruti and Toyota, did it require more differentiation from its Suzuki sibling?

    Published on Aug 11, 2023 06:22:00 PM

    21,780 Views

    Toyota Rumion front quarter

    No sooner did we break our exclusive news on the Rumion – the Toyota-badged Ertiga – than memes, captions and posts started to pop up about Maruti and Toyota’s newest badge swap. Some were certainly funny, while some were thought-provoking. Was this one shared product too many, and should there have been a greater differentiation between the two?

    After all, at their first collaboration – a badge swap of the previous Baleno – they said subsequent models would see greater differentiation, and with the Grand Vitara and Hyryder, we did see a differentiated front and rear design. So then a completely separate top hat would seem like the logical next step. Except it wasn’t.

    That will still happen; the Rumion is certainly no indication of how future shared products would shape up. But should there have been greater differentiation between the Ertiga and Rumion? In a perfect world, yes, but there’s costs and product lifecycle to consider. At this point – five years into the second-generation Ertiga – investing heavily into a differentiated Toyota offering would make no financial sense. So why then is Toyota bothering with its launch?

    Why not? Sure, badge swaps and light makeovers haven’t gone down well in India: case in point, the Nissan Micra and Renault Pulse. But Toyota and Maruti have made their efforts work. The Baleno/Glanza combine has worked; Toyota got access to a new market segment, and  while there is customer overlap, on the whole, numbers have increased for the model. So Suzuki wins too.

    And with the Ertiga/Rumion duo, once again, Toyota enters a new segment, and Suzuki can be confident of overall volumes. The Rumion also nicely complements the Crysta and Hycross (and Vellfire), and builds a neat MPV line-up for Toyota. And speaking of complements, the reason why this product-sharing approach works for Maruti and Toyota is because the two have a very similar brand image. Sure, there are differences, but it’s not like chalk and cheese or Renault and Nissan. Suzuki and Toyota are both Japanese brands, generally known for their reliable products and efficient engines. Both don’t have that flashy image, nor are they held in high regard for sharp handling or driver-focused vehicles. So it’s easy for most of their products to fill each other’s shoes. They really do come off as siblings and not in-laws. Oh, and I gel very well with my in-laws; just saying.

    So just as I’m excited about a completely different top-hat approach, like the Creta/Seltos, I’m also all for grille and badge swaps done by the right partners. They gel well and strengthen the business for the brands and their dealers, and this means a strong foundation for more of each one’s own products. So Suzuki, Toyota, go ahead: share a few more models too, but just keep your other vehicles coming in. Swift Sport, please!

    Also See:

    Opinion: Is Tata missing a trick by not doing a modern-day Sumo?

    Opinion: Why the Citroen C3 Aircross should be priced aggressively

    Comments
    ×
    img
    img
    unknown - 348 days ago

    Ertiga/Rumion is a "long in the tooth" Suzuki product that has begged for a comprehensive update for long, this badge/batch swap tells us that an update is not in the offing?! I wish as a value addition there are at least 6 airbags and a little premium interiors. Suzuki and Toyota are having a cozy win win relationship here in the Indian market and must be the cynosure of all the Indian auto manufacturers with more than a tinge of 'jealousy'!

    Ask Autocar Anything about Car and Bike Buying and Maintenance Advices
    Need an expert opinion on your car and bike related queries?
    Ask Now
    Poll of the month

    Would you buy a CNG bike?

    Yes, the running costs are too good to ignore.

     

    36.34%

    No, CNG comes with too many compromises.

     

    38.64%

    EVs are more affordable to run and greener

     

    25.02%

    Total Votes : 1219
    Sign up for our newsletter

    Get all the latest updates from the automobile universe