Autocar India
PV

Parthasarathy Vedamani

11h

My father-in-law is nearing 60 and is planning to upgrade to an automatic car with a maximum budget of ₹15 lakh. He is currently driving a 10-year-old Swift VDI and is looking for a comfortable, reliable, and value-for-money automatic car for long-term use. Currently, we have shortlisted Maruti Brezza VXI / ZXI Automatic and Mahindra XUV 3XO MX2 Pro AT. We would appreciate suggestions on which would be the better option considering comfort, ease of driving, maintenance, reliability, and overall value for money for senior citizens.

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
4h

Since you're looking for an easy, comfortable automatic car under Rs. 15 lakh, the Maruti Suzuki Brezza ZXI AT is the one you should be looking at. It is very easy to drive in traffic thanks to the light controls, the torque converter automatic shifts smoothly, and the tall seat makes getting in and out easy for a 60-year-old. The ride is calm over broken roads, so daily runs and longer trips feel less tiring. Maruti’s wide service network and low part costs also make life easier over 8-10 years, and resale is usually strong.Two things to note: it is not the quickest thanks to the naturally aspirated 1.5-litre petrol engine that puts out just 103hp, and if the ZXI is over your budget in your city, you'll have to settle for the VXI automatic that will feel a bit basic inside. Pick the Mahindra XUV 3XO MX2 Pro AT only if he wants stronger pull and more features for the money. Overall, for comfort, ease, low upkeep and trust, go for the Brezza automatic.

VehicleMaruti Suzuki Brezza
VehicleMahindra XUV 3XO
Maruti Suzuki Brezza
Maruti Suzuki Brezza
SB

SB

1d

I am a 47 years old, 5 ft tall female. I want to buy my first bike, and I am considering the Jawa 42 Bobber. Is it a good bike for me? I have seen many negative reviews.

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
5h

If your main goal with your machine is to strike poses and look cool on the extremely short spins you make on the weekend, then the Jawa 42 Bobber is a good fit. However, the bike is not practical, it's build quality is still far from the segment benchmark and Classic Legends (parent company of Yezdi, Jawa and BSA) still has a long way to go when it comes to customer satisfaction in terms of service. Considering your short stature, we'd recommend bikes like the RE Hunter 350 and TVS Ronin, which will still give you that Neo retro aesthetic but will not stop short of being good, all-round capable machines at the expense of just looking good. If you decide you want to keep it simple and practical, without spending a lot of cash, a 125cc/160cc bike from brands like TVS, Bajaj, Hero and Honda will be a good choice. This would in fact be our default recommendation considering this is your first bike and you'll need to develop basic motorcycle specific skills like clutch control, smooth gearshifts and throttle control. Evaluate your priorities, take multiple test rides and then make your decision. Also look into each bike's reviews and ownership forums to see which is the most hassle free to live with on a day to day basis. All this will help you make a more informed decision.

Jawa 42 Bobber
Royal Enfield Hunter 350
TVS Ronin
RR

Rahul Rajbhoj

10h

How is the Duster (DCT Evolution variant) for city driving as well as occasional highway use? What long-term issues or problems can I face with this car? Is there a better alternative within the same budget that is also fun to drive and reliable for city usage, considering this uses a wet clutch system?

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
6h

The new Duster DCT Evolution is actually a strong city plus highway package, and the fact that it uses a wet clutch DCT is a key advantage. Unlike dry clutch DCTs, wet clutch systems run the clutches in oil for cooling, which makes them smoother at crawling speeds, better at handling heat and generally more tolerant of heavy stop go traffic. So if your concern is city usability, this is far less worrying than older dry clutch DCTs.That said, it still will not be as seamless at very low speeds as a good torque converter or CVT. On the highway, though, the Duster should feel right at home because the turbo petrol and DCT combination suits open road driving very well, and the Duster has the ingredients to be an engaging driver’s SUV.Long term, the bigger question mark is not the wet clutch gearbox itself, but the fact that this is a brand new product with no long term Indian ownership data yet. Wet clutch DCTs are generally more robust than dry clutch units, but they are still mechanically complex systems, so if something does go wrong out of warranty, repairs will not be cheap. Renault’s service reach and ownership ecosystem also are not as confidence inspiring as some established rivals.If you want a more proven alternative in the same budget, the Kia Seltos HTK IVT is worth serious consideration. It falls in a similar price bracket, uses a naturally aspirated petrol with an IVT automatic that is far smoother in city traffic, and offers a much more proven long term ownership proposition. You will give up some outright performance and driver engagement compared to the Duster turbo DCT, but if reliability and fuss free city use matter more, the Seltos is the safer pick.

VehicleRenault Duster
MS

Manoj S

1d

I currently own a 9-year-old Tata Tiago and am now planning to upgrade to either the Tata Safari Adventure X Plus Diesel Automatic or the Mahindra XUV 7XO AX7 Diesel Automatic. The Safari is around ₹3 lakh cheaper while offering almost similar specifications, except for a few additional luxury features in the XUV 7XO. I live in Bangalore, and my annual running is around 15,000 km, mostly involving city driving with occasional highway trips. Could you please suggest which of these would be the better choice?

Autocar India team

Autocar India

Verified
7h

Mostly Bangalore city uses about 15,000 km a year, and moving up from a Tiago - in that brief, the Tata Safari Adventure X+ Diesel automatic is the better fit. You save around Rs 3 lakh and still get the core things you’ll feel every day: a very comfortable ride over broken roads and speed bumps, a punchy engine, smooth automatic, and loads of space for family and luggage. Coming from a Tata, service and running costs will feel familiar too, which helps in Bangalore.What you give up versus the Mahindra are a few fancy extras and some advanced driver aids. If most of your driving is inside the city with the odd highway trip, you won’t miss them much. The Safari does feel big in narrow lanes and parking spots, and the diesel automatic can feel a touch slow to jump off the line if you stamp on the pedal, so plan gaps.If you do long highway runs often and value safety tech that keeps distance and warns you, the Mahindra XUV 7XO AX7T is worth the extra, and the engine is a bit more refined. Otherwise, for your use and budget, the Safari suits you better.

VehicleTata Safari
VehicleMahindra XUV 7XO