Autocar India
1d

I am looking to buy the Tata Sierra Pure+ DCA petrol, which costs about Rs 19.7 lakh. I am upgrading from a 2011 Hyundai i20 Asta. I do not use the car on a day-to-day basis; it is mostly for weekend use and a family trip every quarter. Maybe after 3-4 years, I might start using it daily for around 25-30km. I like the looks of the Sierra. Please suggest whether I should go ahead with it or consider alternatives. We are a family of four: my wife, my 8-year-old child and my 3-year-old child.

Verified
39m

Your reasons for choosing the Tata Sierra Pure+ DCA petrol make sense. For a family of four that mainly uses the car on weekends and for occasional road trips, the Sierra’s space and comfortable ride are significant advantages. You already like its looks, and that emotional factor matters when the car won’t be used daily; enjoyment every time you take it out is a valid consideration.Be aware that the 1.5L naturally aspirated petrol paired with the DCA feels rather sluggish, particularly when overtaking on highways. The gearbox shifts more slowly than more refined automatics, so acceleration can feel lethargic. In city driving and relaxed cruising, you’ll be fine, and the Sierra is comfortable for family outings and short trips. Because it’s a heavier vehicle, expect modest fuel efficiency; occasional future daily usage of 25–30 km won’t be a dealbreaker, but if you end up using it daily long-term, fuel costs will be noticeably higher.If you’re comfortable with a “lazy” automatic and prioritise space and ride comfort for family trips, stick with the Sierra. If you prefer a livelier driving experience and sharper on-road manners, consider alternatives such as the Kia Seltos with the 1.5L NA and CVT. It won’t match the Sierra for interior space or comfort, but it feels much nicer to drive.

VehicleTata Sierra
VehicleKia Seltos