Long Termer

2015 Tata Zest AMT long-term review, third report

Niggling problems aside, the Zest has been a solid workhorse on our intercity trips.

DETAILS
6
photos

 Being based in Pune, with an office in Mumbai, means frequent trips back and forth, at least a couple of times a month, to wrap up my bit for the magazine. My primary means of covering the 310km round trip for the past few months has been the Tata Zest. I got the car from an ex-colleague who was using it before me, and while it shows 22,353km on the odo as I write this report, I’m responsible for putting only about the last couple of thousand kilometres on it.

It’s been a faithful companion on my Mumbai trips and I really appreciate the fact that it packs the 1.3-litre Quadrajet diesel motor, and that too the 90hp one. It’s got plenty of torque on tap for quick overtakes at highway speeds and when you’re cruising with minimal throttle input, it’s a real slow sipper as well. Out on the Mumbai-Pune expressway, it easily manages 19-20km to the litre, while the overall mileage (which also includes a fair amount of city driving) is just a tad under the 17kpl mark.

Good mileage means it does a fair distance on a tank of diesel.

This XMA variant features the F-Tronic AMT (Automated Manual Transmission) gearbox and I’m impressed at just how fuel efficient the car is. However, I have a fair bit of gripes regarding the way this AMT works. Normally, for any automatic or AMT gearbox, one would assume that the moment you get off the brake after slotting it into ‘D’, the car would start creeping ahead. No such luck here, as the Zest doesn’t budge without throttle input. That’s not a problem if you’re just setting off, but if you’re trying to inch along in bumper-to-bumper traffic, or worse, manoeuvring it in tight parking spaces, you’ll find modulating the power quite tricky. And when driving briskly, though the tiptronic mode is a saving grace to a certain extent, the shifts are just too slow. You get a pronounced head-nod each time the car shifts up and, frankly, it gets annoying really fast. Quite a shame considering that it’s a fairly decent handling machine. Sure, it rolls around a bit, but chucking it around the bends isn’t really a scary affair. And the ride quality is pretty good too.

Speaking of reliability, twice we’ve had the intercooler hose pop off its mounting – once when I was driving and again when my colleague was, before me. Now this isn’t a catastrophic failure, but once that hose pops, you lose turbo pressure and the car goes into ‘limp-home’ mode. It’s an easy fix if you have a pair of pliers to work the hose clip, but you really need to let the engine cool down before you reach for that hose. It’s not an easy reach either. Recently, the car was sent to the company to sort this issue out, and so far, I’ve done three trips to Mumbai and a whole lot of driving around Pune without the problem recurring. Let’s just hope it stays that way. Fingers crossed!

Fact File

General

Price when new 9.74 lakh (on-road, Mumbai)
Maintenance costs None
Faults Intercooler hose
Distance covered 22,353km
comments powered by Disqus

notSet

The 90hp 1.3-litre Quadrajet has plenty of torque on offer. The intercooler hose which popped off is very hard to reach. A solitary cupholder in the centre console simply isn’t enough. The AMT gearbox is slow to shift, in both manual and auto modes. Good mileage means it does a fair distance on a tank of diesel.
We’ve exclusively driven the third-gen Maruti Swift, compared the Dzire with all its compact sedan rivals, and tested the all-new Volvo XC60. That and lots more in the July 2017 issue!
What's in this issue?

Trending Now
Find a car review

Latest Car Reviews

2016 Tata Tiago long term review, third report

2016 Tata Tiago long term review, third report

1 day 17 hours ago
First impressions are said to matter the most. If so, then the Tiago and I...
2016 Fiat Abarth Punto long term review, first report

2016 Fiat Abarth Punto long term review, first report

6 days ago
In this first stint with our new hot hatch resident, sheer driving pleasure...
2017 Tata Tiago AMT review, test drive

2017 Tata Tiago AMT review, test drive

Jun 20, 2017
Tata has introduced a five-speed AMT in the top-spec Tiago and that has made...
2017 Skoda Octavia facelift review, test drive

2017 Skoda Octavia facelift review, test drive

Jun 20, 2017
The Octavia gets some styling tweaks and more features but mechanicals...
2017 Audi A3 Cabriolet review, test drive

2017 Audi A3 Cabriolet review, test drive

Jun 19, 2017
Updated convertible not only gets all the cosmetic and tech upgrades of the...
Latest News
GM dealers to suspend services, go on indefinite strike
US carmaker, dealers say, is forcing them to pick up existing stock from...
7 hours ago   1 picture
Mahindra to exit Moto3 next year
The company has decided to shift its focus towards electric mobility and...
7 hours ago   1 picture
2017 Ducati Multistrada Enduro v Triumph Tiger Explorer XC comparison
The Multistrada 1200 Enduro and the Tiger 1200 Explorer XC are two beasts in...
8 hours ago   18 pictures
Force India could be rebranded as ‘Force One’
Vijay Mallya has been planning a name change for the team to open up more...
8 hours ago   1 picture
Bajaj Pulsar NS160 vs rivals: Specifications comparison
We look at how the Bajaj Pulsar NS160 compares with the Honda CB Hornet...
9 hours ago   1 picture

Autocar Magazine

Issue: 215 | Autocar India: July 2017

We’ve exclusively driven the third-gen Maruti Swift, compared the Dzire with all its compact sedan rivals, and tested the all-new Volvo XC60. That and lots more in the July 2017 issue!
Autocar Magazine
Latest Poll
Should the FCA group launch the Fiat Argo in India?


or View results
Yes, Fiat needs an infusion of new cars
  78%
 
No, they should instead discontinue the brand and focus on Jeep
  22%
TOTAL VOTES: 1059

Vote now
View previous Polls »