Mercedes GLE or Porsche Macan

Choosing between a new Mercedes GLE 350 d and a fully-loaded second-hand 2014 Porsche Macan diesel.

Mercedes GLE or Porsche Macan

I want to know which car I should buy – a brand-new Mercedes GLE 350 diesel or a 2014 Porche Macan diesel with full features, but one that’s been test-driven for 18,000km, for a base price of Rs 86 lakh? Please advise.
Hussain, Bhubaneswar

AAA It really depends on your priorities. If you are looking for an SUV that is spacious and practical, then the Mercedes GLE 350 diesel is a good choice. It is smooth, comfortable and a great highway cruiser. The Macan diesel, however, is a different animal altogether and if you are looking for pure driving pleasure, the Macan is unbeatable. It handles brilliantly and its punchy 3.0-litre V6 diesel is silky smooth and very quick. However, in our view, the Macan is overpriced and the space in the cabin is quite tight compared to the Merc’s.

Copyright (c) Autocar India. All rights reserved.
See more about:  mercedes gle, porsche macan
We’ve exclusively driven the Jeep Compass in India, tell you what the all-new SsangYong Rexton is like, give our first impressions of the third-gen Maruti Dzire and have driven all of Lexus’ India cars. And there’s plenty more inside!
What's in this issue?

comments powered by Disqus
Trending Now

Autocar Magazine

Issue: 214 | Autocar India: June 2017

We’ve exclusively driven the Jeep Compass in India, tell you what the all-new SsangYong Rexton is like, give our first impressions of the third-gen Maruti Dzire and have driven all of...
Autocar Magazine
Latest Poll
Which of these big SUV's would you buy?




or View results
Toyota Fortuner
  27%
 
Ford Endeavour
  51%
 
Mitsubishi Pajero Sport
  7%
 
Isuzu MU-X
  15%
TOTAL VOTES: 1727

Vote now
View previous Polls »