Better crash safety, whose call is it?

The zero star rating for Indian cars in the latest Global NCAP tests has led to a chorus for better safety provisions in vehicles, but whose responsibility is it?

The results are in and of the five Indian cars that underwent crash tests by Global NCAP, all have received a zero star rating. Many are now asking for manufacturers to provide better safety standards and  not wait for legislature. So, should manufacturers oblige? Are we really concerned about safety? And are these tests fair in the first place?

The short answer is no. The Global NCAP tests are not part of Indian safety standards and so, in that sense, not fair. Then again, our regulation standards aren’t representative of real-world crash scenarios either. For the Global NCAP tests, cars are crashed offset against a deformable barrier at 64kph to simulate a possible real-world crash. So, the tests may not be legal or valid but they are relevant.

But just how relevant? Barring the Kwid, which had its airbag-equipped model tested, the Scorpio, Celerio and Eon had the non-airbag models tested. Some manufacturers claim this is unfair but the argument for Global NCAP is that they test the base variant or the ‘minimum’ level of safety in a model on offer.

The lesson here then is, instead of limiting airbags to only the expensive, higher variants, like the norm is here, manufacturers should provide airbags, at least as an option, on all variants. Of course, catering for this option would add to the price of the car.

This is where we as consumers must do our bit. Most drivers use seat belts only to avoid a possible fine and passengers in the back seat are rarely belted up either. Look beyond cars and we can see there is no culture of safety in our everyday lives. People are killed crossing railway tracks, fire escapes are blocked in residences and no one seems to care. It’s high time we accord safety its rightful priority and only then would things like airbags follow.

But airbags are not the only answer. In the absence of proper, meaningful safety regulation, we will only get ‘window dressing’ safety like airbags on structurally weak cars and changes to the overall engineering and build process required to keep passengers safe
will not happen.

Thus, customer concern and regulation must come together; as is typical in any competitive business, a company that is looking for a price advantage will always provide things that customers care about and ignore the rest while meeting the minimum enforced standards.

About the author...

Sergius Barretto

One of our new members on the editorial team Sergius has been a part of the automotive industry for 18 years, fixing, selling, training and consulting on all things automotive. Auto enthusiast by birth. Auto engineer by education. Now auto journalist by profession.

Recent blog entries by Sergius:
We bring you drives of the Maruti Ignis, the Skoda Kodiaq, the new 5-series and take you on a trip from India to Paris in a Renault Kwid. All that and lots more inside!
What's in this issue?

comments powered by Disqus

notSet

Trending Now
Latest News
Porsche 718 Boxster, Cayman launch on February 15
718 siblings will be powered by Porsche’s new 300hp, 2.0-litre...
18 minutes ago   1 picture
KTM 390 Adventure confirmed for India
Design of the adventure tourer has been finalised; will use same engine and...
23 minutes ago   2 pictures
Okinawa Ridge electric scooter launched
Okinawa Autotech’s electric two-wheeler is priced at Rs 43,702...
1 hour ago   1 picture
New Porsche Panamera India launch in March 2017
Initially only the Panamera Turbo will be available; more models including a...
2 hours ago   1 picture
Tata Hexa automatic in high demand
About 60 percent of total bookings made for automatic variants; increase in...
5 hours ago   1 picture

Latest Car Reviews

2017 Maruti Ignis review, test drive

2017 Maruti Ignis review, test drive

4 days ago
The radical Ignis breaks Maruti convention to chase young and funky car buyers.
Maruti S-Cross long-term review, final report

Maruti S-Cross long-term review, final report

Jan 9, 2017
The more we drove it, the more it endeared itself to us.
2016 BMW 330i GT review, test drive

2016 BMW 330i GT review, test drive

Jan 4, 2017
The revered ‘330i’ badge is back, but it now points to a very...
2016 Hyundai Elantra petrol long-term review first report

2016 Hyundai Elantra petrol long-term review first report

Jan 3, 2017
The new executive sedan has an easy-going character that’s best...
Volvo XC90 T8 Excellence review, test drive

Volvo XC90 T8 Excellence review, test drive

Dec 21, 2016
The range-topping Volvo XC90 is designed to save the environment while...

Autocar Magazine

Issue: 209 | Autocar India: January 2017

We bring you drives of the Maruti Ignis, the Skoda Kodiaq, the new 5-series and take you on a trip from India to Paris in a Renault Kwid. All that and lots more inside!
Autocar Magazine
Latest Poll
When seated at the rear do you buckle up?



or View results
Always
  25%
 
Sometimes
  24%
 
Never
  52%
TOTAL VOTES: 587

Vote now
View previous Polls »